We live in a time when many in society believe that children have too many rights. Some would say that children today rule the roost. That children today threaten to call Social Services for a parent looking at them the wrong way. And that Social Services will jail a parent for so much as yelling at their children.
These are assertions that stem from misinformation and a misguided belief that parents have lost their authority. Or that parents are always right. Or that children need to be "put in their place."
The fact is, children do not have much of a voice at all. They have few rights. And even though there are laws that are supposed to protect them from abuse, all too often these laws fail children. Miserably.
There are many signs that a child is being abused. Physical signs. Emotional signs. Signs that a child is being neglected.
But one sign may be overlooked.
A child who steps up to protect another child who is being bullied. Especially when the protector is acting alone.
It's easy to see such a child as a hero. Someone who will protect another at almost any cost. But oftentimes there is something else going on. Something much more serious.
For the sake of making this article more readable, I'll refer to the child as a male. But know that the gender of the child does not predispose them to any particular type of behaviour. A female is just as likely to be a protector as a male.
The abused child may physically and/or emotionally go after the bully. Without fear of injury or harm to himself. And it's not unusual for the child to go after the bully in a way that is over the top.
In such cases, the abused child stands up for the bullied child as a proxy voice. For both the bullied child and himself. He does not have a voice to stop the abuse being endured in his life. But will release the tension by standing up for someone else. Someone he has an opportunity to "save".
These children have a strong sense of right and wrong. And when they see an injustice being perpetrated against someone else who is helpless to protect themselves, they do the speaking up. Both for the bullied child and for themselves.
I was one of those children.
I couldn't prevent or stop the abuse I was facing at the hands of my parents. The system turned a blind eye. But I refused to turn a blind eye when I saw someone being mistreated. I stood up for injustices and the bullied. Even at my own peril.
In fact, I was stronger at protecting others than was at protecting myself.
And when the bullied were my brothers, my sense of what was "right" did them no favours. Though my motives were in the right place, they were misguided. Because my brothers then had to deal with the added bullying of having an older sister who had to "protect" them.
So the next time you see a child stand up for a bullied child, especially in a way that puts the protector at risk, ask yourself: Is this child being abused? Then do the necessary follow-up.
Very interesting article. I would never had considered that a child protecting another child from bullying is actually an abused child. Rather I would have thought he was a well adjusted mature beyond his years child. However, when you think about it what you say makes complete sense.ReplyDelete
This is so true, and it's also the reason why so many therapists are survivors, and why so many who volunteer in shelters or work for different non-profit organizations are survivors. It is so much easier to help others than to help yourself or your own case! I am always running into walls in my own case, but am able to help so many other survivors... Now I just have to find the person who can help my kids and me!ReplyDelete
When I stand up for others, I do it because I can't do otherwise. To do anything else who be to do exactly what all the family members, neighbours and friends did to me - turn a blind eye. When you stand up for someone else either the bully is going to target you and try to redirect and put it on you.ReplyDelete
I disagree for about the proxy voice. When you have experienced injustice you esteem justice or at least I did and do When no one stands up for you, you have to stand up for yourself. You also feel duty bound to stand up for others, knowing what it is like to be undefended you realize the importance.ReplyDelete
Thank you to all who have commented for your thoughts on this matter.ReplyDelete
I also was an abused child who stood up for others. As an abused wife, I helped abused wives who were neighbors. I still try to help the abused with my blog posts. I now have healed enough that I am practicing standing up for myself as well. I no longer spend time with abusive people and I am letting go of past abusers' rules in my head and heart.ReplyDelete
I commend and applaud you, Tanya! Keep standing up for yourself...you're certainly worth it!Delete